It Is Written

The Scottsboro Nine

Three Angels Broadcasting Network

Program transcript

Participants:

Home

Series Code: IIW

Program Code: IIW019214S


00:01 in the following program may not be suitable for children.
00:04 Viewer discretion is advised.
00:07 ♪[theme music]♪
00:26 >>John Bradshaw: This is It Is Written.
00:28 I'm John Bradshaw.
00:29 Thanks for joining me.
00:31 Justice.
00:33 When I say that word, "justice," what do you think of?
00:38 If I asked you for another word for justice,
00:40 what would that word be?
00:42 Fairness?
00:43 That's what I think of.
00:44 Honesty? Integrity?
00:48 What would justice look like in a courtroom setting?
00:51 The fair shake, an even playing field, equity.
00:55 Surely it would mean to be heard, represented,
00:57 for the facts to be made known.
00:59 Justice and truth--
01:01 now, they're closely related, aren't they?
01:03 They're like twins. Surely they are.
01:06 Human beings have always had their challenges
01:08 when it comes to administering justice.
01:11 Any time you have people involved,
01:13 justice is going to be unevenly applied.
01:17 But you'd like to think society will do its best
01:19 to get it right.
01:22 Extreme cases are easy to find.
01:24 A man who'd been convicted for burgling two empty homes
01:28 was arrested on possession of $10 worth of illegal drugs
01:31 and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.
01:36 Hard to call that justice, isn't it?
01:38 Even the judge said it was wrong.
01:40 A man stole a $2.50 pair of socks,
01:43 but it was his third strike, so he, too, was sentenced
01:46 to 25 years to life under California's three-strikes law.
01:50 Justice can be complex,
01:52 and it's often true that the one who can afford
01:55 the best lawyer ends up getting the best justice.
01:59 ♪[soft sad music]♪
02:05 The entire Bible centers around justice,
02:08 or you could say, injustice.
02:11 The central point of the Bible is the cross.
02:14 It's because of the cross that people can be saved.
02:18 That's where Jesus bore the sins of the world: the cross.
02:23 But the death of Jesus on the cross
02:26 was an act of gross injustice.
02:29 Jesus didn't deserve to die on the cross,
02:32 but He died there anyway,
02:34 the victim of the greatest miscarriage of justice
02:38 in the history of the world.
02:41 The pledge of allegiance of the United States of America,
02:44 written in the 1890s and adopted by Congress in 1942,
02:48 goes like this:
02:50 "I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America
02:54 and to the Republic for which it stands,
02:56 one Nation under God, indivisible,
03:00 with liberty and justice for all."
03:03 Now, what did that say?
03:04 "With liberty and justice for all."
03:09 Which is good, in theory.
03:11 Just over a decade before the pledge was adopted by Congress,
03:16 a long journey to justice began for a group of young men.
03:20 It was 1931.
03:22 They boarded a train here in Chattanooga, Tennessee.
03:27 That long journey to justice
03:29 took a detour through some very serious injustice.
03:35 ["Chattanooga Choo Choo" song begins and fades]
03:39 In 1931 the main Chattanooga railroad station was right here.
03:45 Today there's a hotel
03:47 and a little train they call the Chattanooga Choo-Choo,
03:51 named after the song recorded by Glenn Miller and his orchestra,
03:55 the first song to receive a gold record.
03:57 ["Chattanooga Choo Choo" continues and ends]
04:00 Back in the day, trains routinely left the station
04:03 heading west, and nine young men, or boys actually,
04:07 clambered aboard a train a little way down the tracks,
04:11 a train that was heading to Memphis,
04:13 where they hoped to find work.
04:15 It was 1931, right in the middle of the Great Depression.
04:19 There were plenty of hobos riding the rails that day,
04:23 March the 25th.
04:25 The nine boys were looking to make a new start in life.
04:30 They were aged between 12 and 19.
04:33 Ozie Powell, Clarence Norris, Olen Montgomery,
04:36 Willie Roberson, and Charlie Weems were Georgians.
04:40 Haywood Patterson, Eugene Williams,
04:42 and Andrew and Leroy Wright were from Chattanooga.
04:46 Apparently, a fight broke out on the train
04:49 between the black youth and a group of white boys
04:53 after one of the white boys stepped on the hand
04:56 of one of the black boys.
04:58 The white boys were then forced off the train.
05:02 Then they lodged a complaint at the station in Stevenson,
05:06 Alabama.
05:12 When the train stopped in Paint Rock, Alabama,
05:15 about 80 miles from Chattanooga,
05:17 the nine boys were apprehended, and things got rapidly worse.
05:23 About 20 minutes after the youth had been detained,
05:27 one of two white women who had been on the train claimed
05:30 that she and her friend had been raped by the nine black boys.
05:36 They were detained in the jail in Scottsboro, Alabama,
05:39 nine accused rapists-- one just 12 years old,
05:44 and one who had a disease that made it impossible
05:47 for him to have participated in the alleged attack.
05:52 The whole thing was absurd,
05:54 but by evening, several hundred men had gathered
05:57 in front of the jail.
05:58 The mayor of Scottsboro appealed to the crowd to disperse.
06:01 Armed lawmen guarded the jail
06:04 in an attempt to hold off the crowd.
06:06 But that crowd wasn't going anywhere.
06:08 They wanted the nine boys. They intended to lynch them.
06:13 ♪[ominous music]♪
06:15 >>Sheila Washington: It was the Jim Crow era where whites ruled.
06:19 If somebody said a black did it, a black didn't have a chance
06:23 of even making it inside of a courtroom
06:26 before he was hung on a tree.
06:29 And they lived to make it to the courthouse,
06:32 and that night a mob came with a telephone pole,
06:37 ready to knock the door in and go in and get those boys
06:40 and bring them out and hang them,
06:42 and the sheriff steps out in the middle of the crowd and said,
06:45 "Before you get to them, you have to go through me."
06:48 >>John Bradshaw: The governor of the state authorized
06:50 25 armed men to be sent to Scottsboro,
06:53 but by the time they arrived, the crowd had mostly dispersed.
06:57 But if the Scottsboro Nine had survived one night,
07:00 it seemed they wouldn't survive much longer.
07:04 The universe rests upon justice.
07:07 If God were not just, if there were no justice in heaven,
07:11 where would we be?
07:12 First John 1:9 says, "If we confess our sins,
07:17 He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins,
07:20 and to cleanse us [of] all unrighteousness."
07:23 The Bible says that justice and judgment
07:26 are the foundation of God's throne.
07:28 Therefore, people who claim to be followers of God
07:32 must care about justice.
07:34 But for these nine boys, justice would take a backseat
07:38 to injustice as their lives played out.
07:42 I'll be back in a moment.
07:44 ♪[music]♪
07:52 >>John: I want to encourage you to get today's free offer,
07:55 "Evil: The Challenge of the Sinful Heart."
07:58 What do you do about the sin problem?
08:01 How can you be successful in the face of temptation?
08:04 What about the evil that comes against us
08:06 and threatens your life?
08:07 How can you turn that back?
08:10 Call us right now on 800-253-3000,
08:13 800-253-3000,
08:16 or visit us online at iiwoffer.com.
08:19 We'll get it to you right away,
08:21 absolutely free.
08:23 >>John Bradshaw: Thanks for joining me on It Is Written.
08:26 In 1931, three-and-a-half thousand people lived
08:30 in Scottsboro, Alabama.
08:31 It was a farming town,
08:33 suddenly thrust into the national spotlight
08:35 when nine black boys, or young men, aged between 12 and 20,
08:40 were accused of rape by two white girls.
08:43 According to one newspaper, the two girls were treated
08:46 by local physicians for terrible injuries they sustained
08:50 in a crime "too revolting to be printed."
08:53 Except...none of it was true.
08:57 One of the girls said that the boys came after them
09:00 shooting pistols and brandishing knives.
09:03 She claimed that she'd been punched in the face
09:06 and had a knife held to her throat.
09:10 Scottsboro was agitated.
09:12 National guardsmen were brought in to keep large crowds away
09:15 from the jail so that the boys wouldn't be lynched.
09:20 ♪[ominous music]♪
09:21 Instead, they would stand trial.
09:23 You would hope that that would be justice,
09:26 except that a fair trial was impossible.
09:30 The Scottsboro Nine were represented initially
09:33 by a lawyer from Chattanooga, an alcoholic,
09:37 who met with the boys for less than half an hour
09:40 before they went on trial,
09:42 a trial in which their lives were at stake.
09:46 If they were found guilty,
09:47 and society had already declared their guilt,
09:51 they'd be executed.
09:53 Two of the boys were tried first,
09:55 but the trial was a farce.
09:57 There was contradictory testimony.
09:59 One of the women, Victoria Price,
10:01 spoke in great detail about the crimes perpetrated against her,
10:05 but her friend, Ruby Bates, couldn't corroborate much
10:09 of what Miss Price said.
10:11 But what truly shocked the courtroom
10:13 was that one of the nine defendants testified that, yes,
10:17 he had witnessed the attack; yes, the girls had been raped;
10:22 yes, the other eight boys were guilty.
10:26 He said later that the night before the trial
10:29 he was taken from his cell and beaten
10:32 and told that if he wanted to save his life,
10:35 he should testify against the others.
10:38 The two who were tried first were found guilty
10:41 and sentenced to death.
10:43 The crowd in the courtroom celebrated wildly.
10:46 The first trial took a day and a half,
10:48 while the other three trials took less than a day, combined.
10:53 Eight of the Scottsboro Nine were found guilty
10:55 and sentenced to die in the electric chair.
11:00 The Alabama Supreme Court upheld all but one
11:03 of the death sentences.
11:04 They said a 13-year-old defendant shouldn't have been
11:07 tried as an adult.
11:09 But the United States Supreme Court overturned the verdicts,
11:13 saying that the boys had been denied competent legal counsel.
11:17 There are tons of details we could go into.
11:21 Some of the rhetoric was...
11:23 well, not the sort of thing I'd want to repeat here.
11:26 Justice?
11:27 There was no justice afforded these boys.
11:29 It was patently obvious they hadn't raped anyone at all,
11:33 that there hadn't even been a rape.
11:35 But this kind of thing happened all the time.
11:37 A black defendant, an accusation,
11:40 an execution, if not a lynching, and life went right on.
11:44 It was the 1930s.
11:46 Slavery had ended 70 years or so earlier,
11:49 but racism had not.
11:51 And in the South,
11:52 African-Americans were routinely discriminated against.
11:56 The system guaranteed it.
11:59 Now, this is the sort of story that people in a free country
12:02 would listen to and say, "That had to have happened
12:05 somewhere else, in some banana republic."
12:08 But it didn't.
12:09 It happened in "the land of the free and the home of the brave."
12:13 Nine young men, nine boys, accused of having committed
12:17 a ghastly crime, that brought with it the ultimate penalty,
12:21 levied against them by a society that was determined to keep
12:25 African-Americans in their place.
12:28 Now, of course, not all white people agreed
12:31 with this behavior,
12:32 not even all whites in the South.
12:34 But this is the way the system worked.
12:36 The belief was that no white woman
12:38 who accused a black man of rape could possibly be lying.
12:43 So an accused Negro was a guilty Negro.
12:46 And even if he wasn't, penalties like these would reinforce
12:50 the power structure that existed.
12:53 During a constitutional convention 30 years earlier,
12:56 Alabama's political leaders stated that their goal
12:59 was to secure permanent white supremacy in Alabama.
13:05 Justice?
13:07 The retrial was held in Decatur, Alabama,
13:10 about 80 miles from Scottsboro, southwest of Huntsville.
13:14 The thought was this would give the boys
13:16 a shot at a fairer trial.
13:18 But the overwhelming view in Decatur
13:20 was that the boys were as guilty as sin.
13:24 During the trial in Decatur,
13:27 one of the physicians who had examined the two young women
13:30 told the judge that the women were lying.
13:34 The judge urged the physician to testify to that end in court.
13:38 The doctor explained to the judge
13:41 that there's no way he could do that.
13:43 If he testified against the two women,
13:46 if he testified in favor of the nine black boys,
13:50 there was no way he'd be able to go home to Scottsboro.
13:54 He said to the judge, "God knows I want to"--
13:56 that's testify and tell the truth--"but I can't."
14:02 >>Sheila: The timeframe, people were scared.
14:04 When you had no law,
14:06 and you will have the Klan to come after you,
14:09 and you see a mob outside of your house with white robes on,
14:13 that was fearful not only to blacks,
14:15 but more fearful to whites, because they know,
14:19 "This is going to happen to me
14:20 just like it's happened to the blacks."
14:23 But he had a conscience.
14:25 Although it was six years later, he told the truth.
14:30 >>John Bradshaw: The Scottsboro boys were now being represented
14:33 by a brilliant New York City attorney named Samuel Leibowitz,
14:38 who exposed the prosecution's case for exactly what it was.
14:42 By now the NAACP were involved in supporting the boys,
14:46 as was the Communist Party, who saw the trial as an opportunity
14:50 to try to grow their influence.
14:53 One of the women actually recanted and said
14:55 that there was no attack,
14:57 no rape, that the story was all made up.
15:00 But the jury found the boys guilty again.
15:04 Again they faced the death penalty.
15:06 But again the convictions were overturned
15:08 because of Alabama's practice of excluding blacks from juries.
15:13 So they were tried again.
15:16 One of the boys was found guilty and sentenced
15:18 to 75 years in prison.
15:21 It was the only time a black man had ever been found guilty
15:24 of the rape of a white woman in Alabama
15:27 and not been sentenced to death.
15:30 Another was sentenced to 105 years,
15:32 another to 99 years.
15:35 Charges were dropped against four of the boys,
15:38 but by then they'd spent six years in prison
15:41 for a crime that had not been committed.
15:45 Ultimately, all of the boys were freed.
15:48 One served 12 years, another a total of 19,
15:53 one was paroled 15 years after the boys were apprehended,
15:57 and there was no fairytale ending.
15:59 None of the boys went on to be a businessman or a politician.
16:03 Not one graduated from college or even high school.
16:07 None of them became a minister.
16:09 This was simply a tragedy.
16:12 Nine poor, poorly educated boys,
16:15 the most vulnerable members of society, were falsely accused,
16:20 deprived of a fair trial.
16:22 The intent at first was to lynch them, then execute them,
16:26 then put them away for as long as possible.
16:29 Their lives were ruined.
16:32 >>Sheila: I realize the state of Alabama had dug a hole so deep
16:36 that they was too embarrassed to say,
16:38 "We made a mistake," and come out and admit they're wrong.
16:44 Instead, they held on to these boys' lives
16:46 until they almost just killed them.
16:49 They squished the life out of them in prison.
16:53 >>John: This whole sorry thing shows us how hatred
16:56 and ignorance and distrust and vilification can destroy lives.
17:01 And not only the lives of the hated,
17:05 but also the lives of the haters.
17:08 People had to live with what they'd done
17:09 for the rest of their lives.
17:12 And of course, they did.
17:15 So how do you get this out of society?
17:17 There is a way.
17:19 We'll look at that in just a moment.
17:21 ♪[music]♪
17:30 >>John: I want to encourage you to get today's free offer,
17:33 "Evil: The Challenge of the Sinful Heart."
17:36 What do you do about the sin problem?
17:39 How can you be successful in the face of temptation?
17:42 What about the evil that comes against us
17:44 and threatens your life?
17:45 How can you turn that back?
17:47 Call us right now on 800-253-3000,
17:51 800-253-3000,
17:54 or visit us online at iiwoffer.com.
17:57 We'll get it to you right away,
17:59 absolutely free.
18:01 >>John: Five loaves.
18:03 Two fish.
18:04 One little boy.
18:06 A great Savior.
18:08 And more than 5,000 people fed, with food left over.
18:14 Join me for "Great Chapters of the Bible: John [Chapter] 6,"
18:18 the remarkable story of a little boy who shared his lunch
18:22 with Jesus, for Jesus to then share it with thousands
18:26 and thousands of people.
18:28 It's also the chapter where Jesus speaks words of truth
18:32 and life, and then watches as almost everybody in the crowd
18:37 turns their back on Jesus and walks away from Him
18:41 and the blessing He offers.
18:43 John chapter 6, where Jesus said,
18:45 "I am the bread of life."
18:48 Don't miss this great chapter of the Bible.
18:51 Join me for John chapter 6.
18:54 Brought to you by It Is Written TV.
19:01 >>John Bradshaw: It was a colossal miscarriage of justice,
19:04 carried out on American soil-- and not back in the Dark Ages--
19:09 in the 1930s.
19:11 And in the 1940s, while Americans were fighting
19:13 for freedom in Europe and the Pacific,
19:16 they were withholding justice from one of their own,
19:19 simply due to the color of a person's skin.
19:23 So how does a society get past this sort of thing?
19:27 You can change laws,
19:28 but you can't legislate a change of heart.
19:31 Education helps.
19:33 Time.
19:34 You'd hope that as one generation dies off,
19:36 it's replaced with a more enlightened generation.
19:39 And no doubt that's happened to a great extent.
19:42 Alabama isn't the same state it was in the 1930s.
19:46 America isn't the same country.
19:48 But it would be foolish to think that there's no racism
19:51 or racists or hate.
19:54 Of course there are.
19:56 So how do you get rid of that?
19:58 Only the gospel of Jesus can change a sinful human heart.
20:04 Paul wrote to the Corinthians and said,
20:06 "Therefore, if any man be in Christ, he is a new creature:
20:10 old things are passed away;
20:13 behold, all things are become new."
20:15 That's 2 Corinthians 5:17.
20:17 Speaking of heaven, the Bible says,
20:19 "But there shall by no means enter it anything that defiles."
20:25 God told Moses that some people would have their names
20:28 blotted out of His book.
20:31 Heaven isn't a place for hate-- or hateful people.
20:37 If there's someone who sympathizes with the plight
20:39 of the Scottsboro boys, it's Jesus.
20:43 He came to the world, according to the Bible,
20:45 "to seek and save that which was lost."
20:48 He came to the world to make known to the world
20:51 what the Father was truly like.
20:53 He came to demonstrate love.
20:55 He came to the world to, to lift people up.
20:58 He gave hope to tax collectors and to harlots and fishermen
21:02 and farmers.
21:03 And He refused to condemn even those who nailed Him
21:07 to the cross.
21:08 The Scottsboro boys, uneducated, naïve,
21:13 couldn't have saved themselves
21:14 if they'd lived a hundred lifetimes.
21:17 Even a lawyer as sharp as Samuel Leibowitz
21:19 could only win acquittals for four of the boys.
21:23 Four were prosecuted and given lengthy sentences.
21:26 Two of them escaped, and two were paroled.
21:30 In a similar way, Isaiah said Messiah would be oppressed,
21:34 afflicted, and taken "as a lamb to the slaughter."
21:38 But why?
21:39 Why would He allow Himself to go through that?
21:42 Hebrews 2:18 says, "For in that He Himself has suffered,
21:46 being tempted, He is able to aid those who are tempted."
21:51 The passage states that because Jesus as a human being
21:55 has gone through what we've gone through in facing temptation,
21:59 He is able to aid; He's able to help us in what we go through.
22:04 Jesus knows what it's like to be tempted.
22:07 So when you're tempted, you can go to One who knows
22:10 from experience what you're going through.
22:13 Jesus knows what it's like to be rejected.
22:16 Even His own family members turned against Him.
22:19 His closest followers fled from Him.
22:22 His own church gave Him up to die on a cross.
22:29 And Jesus knows what it's like to be falsely accused.
22:33 He knows injustice from experience.
22:36 This is Matthew 26, starting in verse 59:
22:39 "Now the chief priests, the elders, and all the council
22:43 sought false testimony against Jesus to put Him to death,
22:47 but found none.
22:48 Even though many false witnesses came forward, they found none.
22:52 But at last two false witnesses came forward and said,
22:56 'This fellow said, "I am able to destroy the temple of God
23:00 and to build it in three days."'"
23:02 False accusations. Truth wasn't being pursued here.
23:06 When Jesus said that they would see the Son of Man
23:09 coming on the clouds of heaven, that was it.
23:13 The high priest cried, "Blasphemy!"
23:15 And the crowd said, "He is deserving of death!"
23:19 And then began a stream of indignities that didn't stop
23:23 until Jesus was dead on a cross.
23:27 So now, this Jesus, who was so poorly treated,
23:31 the victim of the greatest miscarriage of justice
23:34 in the history of the universe, how did He treat people
23:38 who are actually deserving of the full penalty of the law?
23:42 Remember, "The wages of sin is death,"
23:44 according to Romans 6:23.
23:46 So how did Jesus treat people?
23:48 To the thief on the cross He said,
23:51 "You will be with me in paradise."
23:54 A woman taken in adultery, a victim herself,
23:58 is brought into the presence of Jesus by a group of men.
24:01 Jesus ignored the men at first,
24:04 simply writing on the ground with His finger.
24:07 John 8:7 says, "So when they continued asking Him,
24:11 He lifted up Himself and said unto them,
24:14 'He that is without sin among you,
24:17 let him first cast a stone at her.'"
24:20 Justice could easily have said, "She deserves to die."
24:24 But in this case, justice said, "You're a bunch of hypocrites,
24:28 and there's a better way to deal with this woman's situation."
24:31 Verse 9 says, "And they which heard it,
24:34 being convicted by their own conscience,
24:37 went out one by one,
24:38 beginning at the eldest, even unto the last:
24:42 and Jesus was left alone,
24:44 and the woman standing in the midst."
24:47 Jesus then asked the woman where her accusers had gone.
24:50 "Has no one condemned you?" Jesus asked.
24:53 She answered and said, No, no one has accused me.
24:57 And then Jesus said some of the most wonderful,
24:59 hopeful words in the entire Bible:
25:02 "Neither do I condemn you."
25:05 And he urged her to go on her way "and sin no more."
25:09 [train horn blaring, wheels clacking]
25:11 God is a God of justice and forgiveness.
25:14 He forgave David and Solomon and Manasseh and others
25:17 for their, for their terrible sins.
25:20 In Psalm 136, the Bible says 26 times in 26 verses
25:25 that God's mercy endures forever.
25:28 It often takes real time for justice to finally be served.
25:33 According to the book of Revelation,
25:35 the Christ of heaven will one day declare,
25:37 "He that is unjust, let him be unjust still:
25:41 and he which is filthy, let him be filthy still:
25:44 and he that is righteous, let him be righteous still:
25:47 and he that is holy, let him be holy still."
25:50 And then He says, "And, behold, I come quickly;
25:54 and my reward is with me,
25:55 to give every man according as his work shall be."
25:59 Justice will be done.
26:03 It isn't too much to desire justice in this world.
26:06 It isn't too much to expect justice.
26:08 Justice is the right of everyone.
26:11 But justice in the hands of flawed human beings
26:14 will never be perfect or perfectly administered.
26:17 But one day, one day when there's no more sin,
26:20 one day when there's no more death,
26:22 one day when there's no more hate,
26:24 one day when there's no more bitterness,
26:26 one day when sin has run its course,
26:29 one day, one soon day, there'll be no more injustice.
26:33 One day Jesus will return, and when He does,
26:36 everything will happen at heaven's behest.
26:39 We look forward to that day,
26:41 and we say with John who wrote Revelation,
26:44 "Even so, come, Lord Jesus!"
26:48 >>John: Thank you for remembering that It Is Written
26:50 exists because of the kindness of people just like you.
26:54 To support this international life-changing ministry,
26:57 please call us now at 800-253-3000.
27:01 You can send your tax-deductible gift
27:03 to the address on your screen,
27:04 or you can visit us online at itiswritten.com.
27:08 Thank you for your prayers and for your financial support.
27:11 Our number again is 800-253-3000,
27:15 or you can visit us online at itiswritten.com.
27:19 >>John Bradshaw: Let's pray together now.
27:21 Our Father in heaven,
27:22 we thank You that Your plan for our future and for our eternity
27:26 is perfect.
27:27 Keep us until then.
27:29 And as we live in a world that is so often marked by injustice,
27:32 give us hearts that are one with Yours.
27:34 We pray for justice in the world,
27:37 but we pray for the heart that will remain constant
27:39 no matter what we face.
27:42 We thank You for the hope that we have in the return of Jesus.
27:45 Take our hearts now; make them Yours,
27:47 not just now but forever.
27:49 We pray and we thank You in Jesus' name.
27:53 Amen.
27:54 Thanks so much for joining me today.
27:56 I look forward to seeing you again next time.
27:58 Until then, remember:
28:00 "It is written, 'Man shall not live by bread alone,
28:04 but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God.'"
28:08 ♪[theme music]♪


Home

Revised 2020-02-18